Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

User avatar
Vortex
Murtaugh's hunter
Posts: 12140
Joined: 03 Dec 2012 17:11
Location: Spain

Re: Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

Post by Vortex »

Last voting day!
User avatar
Vortex
Murtaugh's hunter
Posts: 12140
Joined: 03 Dec 2012 17:11
Location: Spain

Re: Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

Post by Vortex »

Voting period has finished. Thank you all for your vote!

EDIT: here are the results!

WINNER: The Kakama (43 points)

RUNNER-UP: sunshine philosophy (34 points)
THIRD PLACE: mentalEngineer (32 points)
FOURTH PLACE: Ko9 (21 points)
FIFTH PLACE: reed (15 points)
SIXTH PLACE: WorldisQuiet5256 (14 points)
User avatar
Vortex
Murtaugh's hunter
Posts: 12140
Joined: 03 Dec 2012 17:11
Location: Spain

Re: Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

Post by Vortex »

Reminder: this thread will be periodically reopened for each issue of the contest, the voting period consists of the first 4 days of the month after the submission period. You can vote until October 5th at 0:01 AM.

Instructions: assign a number (1,2,3,...) to each fanart in increasing order, from least liked to most liked (remember that you can't vote for your own fanarts!). The points from all voters will be summed and the winner will be the one with most points. For more detailed instructions, please refer to the rules and guidelines.

Here are the current rules and guidelines. Please read them carefully, you must accept them to enter the contest.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Image
(Credit to Empoeria for the banner)

Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest #2- September 2017

This month's entries:

grokenos82 (I)
Ko9 (I)
o.7.0.7 (I)
Aquaerellum13
grokenos82 (II)
grokenos82 (III)
Prupp (I)
Prupp (II)
reed (I)
mentalEngineer
o.7.0.7 (II)
Ko9 (II)
Ko9 (III)
Apocrypha
reed (II)
reed (III)
Prupp (III)

Here is an example of vote (does not count):

grokenos82 (I) - 1
Ko9 (I) - 2
o.7.0.7 (I) - 3
Aquaerellum13 - 4
grokenos82 (II) - 5
grokenos82 (III) - 6
Prupp (I) - 7
Prupp (II) - 8
reed (I) - 9
mentalEngineer - 10
o.7.0.7 (II) - 11
Ko9 (II) - 12
Ko9 (III) - 13
Apocrypha - 14
reed (II) - 15
reed (III) - 16
Prupp (III) - 17
User avatar
Rever Man
lost in subnet
Posts: 39
Joined: 18 Sep 2016 17:57
Location: Canada

Re: Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

Post by Rever Man »

o.7.0.7 (I) - 17
Apocrypha - 16
o.7.0.7 (II) - 15
reed (I) 14
Prupp (I) 13
Ko9 (III) 12
grokenos82 (II) 11
grokenos82 (III) 10
Ko9 (II) 9
reed (III) 8
grokenos82 (I) 7
Prupp (II) 6
Aquaerellum13 5
Ko9 (I) 4
reed (II) 3
mentalEngineer 2
Prupp (III) 1
Last edited by Rever Man on 01 Oct 2017 00:20, edited 1 time in total.
Rever Man
User avatar
ENIHCAMBUS
karma portal traveller
Posts: 8653
Joined: 04 Feb 2013 22:17
Location: Pastel Lands.

Re: Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

Post by ENIHCAMBUS »

Ko9 III (Franku) - 1
MentalEngineer (Desert) - 2
Ko9 I (Face) - 3
Aquaerellum (Museum) - 4
Reed II (Librarian Bleeding) - 5
Ko9 II (West-Minster) - 6
o.7.0.7 I (Lighthouse) - 7
o.7.0.7 II (Flagpoint) - 8
Prupp II (Sea) - 9
Grokenos I (Chapel) - 10
Prupp III (Spoop) - 11
Grokenos II (Librarian) - 12
Prupp I (Hovering Structure) - 13
Reed III (Weremorph) - 14
Grokenos III (Characters) - 15
Apocrypha (Sign) - 16
Reed I (Aqueduct) - 17
ENIHCAMBUS: State of the Art Scanning!
🧐
User avatar
Jatsko
karma portal traveller
Posts: 5997
Joined: 26 May 2014 11:20

Re: Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

Post by Jatsko »

grokenos82 (I) - 14
Ko9 (I) - 7
o.7.0.7 (I) - 11
Aquaerellum13 - 3
grokenos82 (II) - 8
grokenos82 (III) - 9
Prupp (I) - 12
Prupp (II) - 2
reed (I) - 16
mentalEngineer - 1
o.7.0.7 (II) - 13
Ko9 (II) - 10
Ko9 (III) - 6
reed (II) - 5
reed (III) - 15
Prupp (III) - 4

Also, I've spotted a problem with this voting setup: People who have submitted more fanarts have a greater chance of winning. And that doesn't have anything to do with the quality of their work.

For this contest, for example, if you submit only one fanart then the highest point value you can give to someone else's work is 16. But if you submit three, then the highest value you can give to another work is 14. Therefore if you submit more stuff it's impossible for you to give the same amount of points to someone else who might give to you because they submitted less work.

Sort of like the problem posed by cross-country racing if you took the requirement of 4 or 5 scoring runners out, but reversed.
Last edited by Jatsko on 01 Oct 2017 00:47, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Prupp
subnet technician
Posts: 493
Joined: 04 Jan 2013 14:25
Location: 888
Contact:

Re: Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

Post by Prupp »

@Apo, true!

I'm doing points, not position:

14. reed I
13. groken I
12. reed III
11. o7 II
10. apo
9. o7 I
8. ko9 I
7. ko9 II
6. groken III
5. ko9 III
4. groken II
3. mental
2. reed II
1. aqua
User avatar
Jatsko
karma portal traveller
Posts: 5997
Joined: 26 May 2014 11:20

Re: Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

Post by Jatsko »

Also, now that I think about it, we should make a rule that if you submit work, you must also vote.
User avatar
o.7.0.7
lost in subnet
Posts: 57
Joined: 19 Mar 2017 22:12
Contact:

Re: Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

Post by o.7.0.7 »

11- grokenos82 (I)
5- Ko9 (I)
(x) o.7.0.7 (I)
3- Aquaerellum13
10- grokenos82 (II)
8- grokenos82 (III)
12- Prupp (I)
4- Prupp (II)
14- reed (I)
2- mentalEngineer
(x) o.7.0.7 (II)
9- Ko9 (II)
6- Ko9 (III)
13- Apocrypha
7- reed (II)
15- reed (III)
1- Prupp (III)

Good luck everyone :D
Last edited by o.7.0.7 on 01 Oct 2017 07:48, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
mentalEngineer
subnet technician
Posts: 290
Joined: 03 Jan 2015 14:04
Location: Pixelmachine

Re: Pastel Land Forum Fanart Contest - Voting thread

Post by mentalEngineer »

reed (I) - 16
o.7.0.7 (I) - 15
grokenos82 (I) - 14
reed (III) - 13
grokenos82 (III) - 12
o.7.0.7 (II) - 11
grokenos82 (II) - 10
Apocrypha - 9
Prupp (I) - 8
Ko9 (I) - 7
Aquaerellum13 - 6
Prupp (II) - 5
Ko9 (II) - 4
Ko9 (III) - 3
reed (II) - 2
Prupp (III) - 1

Great that a lot more people got involved!
Through every problem, raw persistence will prevail.
Locked